The scope for a direct link between inequality and investment widens substantially once we give. Recent research suggests that an unequal distribution of income can hamper growth. In this paper, we are going to refer to the concept of economic equality. The thesis first analyzes the possibility of the kuznets curve in china rural area theoretically. Summary data from developing economies indicate that the earlier phases of economic development tend to be characterized by increasing income inequality, as those engaged in the small but growing modern sector of the economy pull away from those still left in agriculture and other subsistence activities. The paper empirically investigates, in the context of african countries, the determinants of income distribution and inequality, the effect of inequality on economic growth, and the channels through which inequality affects growth. Gdp and population data 19692007 from 36 nations and regions, comprising the entire global economy and population, demonstrate a global.
Dec 08, 2014 the gap between rich and poor is bad for economic growth because it limits access to education for the bulk of the workforce, according to the oecd. Economic growth rising inequality and rapid growth. Income inequality, economic growth, and the effect of. Determinants of income inequality and its effects on economic. Trends in income inequality and its impact on economic growth.
This paper compares two popular views on the evolution of income inequality. Could policies aimed solely at growth be responsible. The third section presents the econometric model adopted to explain this rise inequality. Economic growth, income inequality, adf test, regression analysis. Economic growth and income inequality 3 groups that, judged by their secular levels, migrate upward or downward on the income scale. Kaldor worried about the inevitability of crises under capitalism, and faster growth accompanied by burgeoning inequality, he saw as a recipe for ongoing crises. The relationship between income inequality and economic growth can be examined from the results of fig. The kuznets curve for the environment and economic growth. The russianborn simon kuznets left soviet russia in 1922, emigrating to new york. One of the major stylized facts about longrun processes of economic development is the kuznets curvethe inverseu shaped pattern of inequality. Using a sample of 80 countries from the 1980s, the author shows that two types of factors explain variations in income inequality. The second group second group of research are based on mediumterm analysis of inequality and growth using panel or longitudinal data li and zou 1998, atkinson et al 2011 3. Simon kuznets the history of economic thought website.
Kuznets believed that inequality would follow an inverted u shape as it rises and then falls again with the increase of income percapita. However, the latter result depends on the data source used for the index of income inequality. The kuznets curve and the inequality process munich. What factors determine the secular level of and trends of income inequality the data. Inequality is then expected to decrease when a certain level of average income is reached and the processes of industrialization democratization and the rise of the welfare state allow for the benefits from rapid growth, and increase the percapita income. Inequality, economic growth and economic performance. It follows that the aftertax return to capital could be unchanged or lowerhigher compared to that evaluated at the egalitarian benchmark, which in turn produces the. There are continuous debates about the relationship between the environment and economic growth. Pdf inequality and economic growth in subsaharan africa. This paper explores the question of structural transformation and income distribution through the eyes of simon kuznets, the pioneer in such analysis. Jul 16, 2014 the inequality and economic growth tradeoff. Wang and wong 2009 show that greenfield fdi improves economic growth while.
Perhaps surprisingly, the fraction of inequality attributable to circumstances is usually quite smallin the advanced democracies, approximately 20%. May 11, 2017 much has been written about the relationship between inequality and economic development, but theory remains inconclusive. Does inequality in the distribution of income increase or decrease in the course of a countrys economic growth. Kuznets posits that there exists a tradeoff between growth and inequality, at least during early phases of economic modernisation. A regional perspective shibalee majumdar and mark partridge egalitarianism refers to the doctrine of the equality of mankind and the desirability of political, economic and social equality. The rise of income inequality amidst the deceleration of gdp growth must rank as two of. Prior to world war i, measures of gnp were rough guesses, at best. The kuznets hypothesis suggests that inequality is low at a lower income level but later increases at higher income level with economic growth. Grossman princeton university elhanan helpman harvard university and cifar june 30, 2016 abstract we introduce rm and worker heterogeneity into a model of innovationdriven endogenous growth. Lewis and kuznets on economic growth and income inequality.
When income is more concentrated in the hands of a few individuals, this can lead to less demand by the general population and lower investment in education and health, impairing longterm growth. Economic growth, financial development, and income inequality 15 in columns 79, when the stock market capitalization to gdp ratio is used as the proxy for financial development, there is no evidence of the ushaped effect. Noting increasing economic equality in three developed nations and using a theoretical economic model, kuznets hypothesized that economic development was associated with initial increasing economic inequality followed by decreasing economic inequality. The relationship between economic growth and income inequality.
In a seminal paper, kuznets 1955 argued that as countries developed, income inequality. Income inequality and economic growth 321 wealth and income becomes unequal, the median voter now could choose the same or a higherlower tax rate on capital income. Widespread increases in income inequality have raised concerns about their potential impact on our societies and economies. The starting point for the theoretical literature on the relationship between growth and income inequality is the kuznets hypothesis. But according to kuznets hypothesis, that same economic inequality is expected to decrease when a certain level of average income is reached and the processes associated with industrialization, such as democratization and the development of a welfare state, take hold. One reason for this is the lack of data on circumstance variables in empirical research. Income inequality and economic growth international. Even if we had data to approximate the income structure just outlined, the broad question posed at the starthow income inequality changes in the process of a countrys economic growth could be. Jones stanford university and national bureau of economic research jihee kim korea advanced institute of science and technology top income inequality rose sharply in the united states over the last 40 years but increased only slightly in france and japan. Pdf economic growth, income inequality and environment.
In the case of large income inequality, economy makes use of resources of. Inequality and economic performance a brief overview to theories of growth and distribution by francisco h. Growth versus change in inequality in a crosssection of countries. Here, we argue that all behaviors and accomplishments of children should be. The relationship between aggregate output and income inequality is central in macroeconomics. Trends in income inequality and its impact on economic. Technological changes and globalization are often argued as the causes of the job polarization and the expansion of income. For richer countries, however, active income redistribution appears to involve a tradeoff between the benefits of greater inequality and a reduction in overall economic growth. Barro further shows that the overall relationship between income inequality and growth and investment is weak. Kuznets estimated the national income accounts during world war ii and compared them with national product during world war i 1945, especially with respect to whether the war effort impinged on the civilian economy or came out of an expansion of total product. Introduction the recently increasing availability of income distribution data has led to a growing empirical literature regarding the in. Thus the relationship between income distribution and income level can be described by an inverted ucurve. Whether one uses factor shares or normatively more desirable indicators of income inequality such as the gini index, there is very little evidence that inequality is good for growth.
One of most common policies to reduce income inequality is to increase government spending in social welfare. Economic growth and income concentration and their effects. Economic growth, income inequality and environment. This paper investigates the effects of corruption on economic growth and in come distribution in african countries. More specifically, it attempts to look at how a high level of income inequality affects economic growth, and searches for possible links between the two. Morrisson and murtin 2011b that at a broad, historical level, trade, growth and inequality have been positively correlated. Tatsuyuki otas article in the palgrave communications, july 25, 2017. The relationship between economic growth and income inequality nasfi fkili wahiba researchunit enterprise economy environment higherinstitute of management, university of gabes,tunisia. This is the prediction of the kuznets relationship that inequality improves as income expands. Does inequality in the distribution of income increase or decrease in the course of a countrys economic. The relationship between income inequality and economic. In 1946 he published a volume that extended the national income accounts back to 1869. By noting patterns of income inequality in developed and underdeveloped countries, he proposed that as countries experienced economic growth, the income inequality first increases and then decreases.
The third group of studies includes the panel data analysis of the correlation between. The evidence basically supports the common sense conclusion. It argues that kuznets 1955 paper stands the test of time in that it provides illuminating insights into current phenomena like the evolution of chinese inequality. Subsequently, the kuznets curve has been applied to the evolution of pollution levels of countries through their development process. Relationship between government quality, economic growth.
Instead, it has decreased in taiwan and stabilized in south korea. Effects of income inequality on economic growth vox, cepr. This paper addresses the specification of the econometric models used in the paper level of development, rate of economic growth, and income inequality by jih y. Rising corporate concentration, declining trade union power, and. Simon kuznets, economic growth and income inequality. There exists many mixed theories and beliefs on how, if at all, income inequality and economic growth relate. However, the trend in overall economic growth rate by income group seems to be on the gradual decrease as shown by the declining average growth rate. The middle income class also plays an important role in political stability acemoglu and robinson, 2006. The gini concentration ratio is the preferred measure of income inequality in economics. Newman university college london november 14, 2003 abstract 1 introduction if the world is often skeptical of what economists have to tell them about trade policy, it is at least in part because they suspect that economists live. The regression model encompassing the impact of economic growth and income inequality on poverty reflects that income inequality increases poverty while economic growth decreases poverty.
In this paper, we will present a theoretical literature of the impact of income inequality on economic growth. A schumpeterian model of top income inequality charles i. The hypothesis of the relationship between economic growth and income inequality under conditions is always regulated by the. Economic growth and income inequality american economic. In more recent data, a link between growth and income inequality can be seen in a cross section. America actually ranks among the worst countries when it comes to income inequality. A russianamerican economist and statistician who won the 1971 nobel memorial prize in economic sciences for his research on economic growth. Corruption, economic growth, and income inequality in africa. Kuznets s plan to use national income measures to describe and explain the longterm economic trends of the industrial nations was formulated in the late 1930s. The kuznets curve simon kuznets 1955, was first used to describe the progression of economic inequality as countries develop. The empirical result on the relationship between economic growth and income distribution also fails to support the conventional invertedu kuznets curve. It describes the finding that inequality first increases and then decreases.
Moreover, he believed that the political system governing the operation of a particular nationstate might turn out to be an important variable in explaining economic growth. New oecd research shows that when income inequality rises, economic growth falls. Linked effects of inequality in health and education. This paper examines two closely related empirical hypotheses. The reasoning was that in order to experience growth. This column argues that greater income inequality raises the economic growth of poor countries and decreases the growth of high and middle income countries. Section 2 will rst present a few measures on how inequality can be assessed and what these numbers look like for brazil. Growth, trade, and inequality national bureau of economic. Sustainable consumption, report of a symposium on january 1920, ministry of the environment, oslo, norway. This will result in upward mobility on the income ladder, and a middle class of income earners will emerge, thereby improving the gini coefficient. The kuznets curve and inequality adam smith institute. The effective market is only available under certain conditions j.
Economic growth, financial development, and income inequality the paper finds that financial development contributes to reducing inequality up to a point, but as financial development proceeds further, it contributes to greater inequality. Leaving aside the case of east asian countries where kuznets invertedu hypothesis regarding changes in inequality as a result of economic growth does not apply to a number of other countries, both the developed and developing countries, kuznets inverted uhypothesis seems to apply well. This relationship is typically perceived to be negative, but the concept of the environmental kuznets curve ekc hypothesis indicates the economic growth is the solution for the eventual protection of the environment bruyn, 2000. Studies of income inequality and economic growth have been well conducted by many other scholars and organizations. No government agency collected data to compute gnp, and no private economic researcher did so systematically, either. Economic growth, financial development, and income inequality. Statistics show that inequality of income has increased since the early 1980s as the rate of economic growth has declined from 11. The relationship between income inequality and economic growth in oecd countries, including south korea hyuntak lee, m. A new twist in the link between inequality and economic. Many economists have long believed that income dispari ties increase in the early stages of development, making the poor relatively worse off. In light of this, it argues for a range of policies that would increase both equity and economic wellbeing. Inequality and economic growth theoretical and applied economics. Abstract to reduce income inequality, governments adopt various policies.
It was no surprise, then, that kuznets took his masters creed to heart. We find that a high level of inequality reduces gdp growth, but its. The next section presents the trends in growth and inequality and makes some important observations regarding the shortcomings of the kuznets curve. Annual income levels before taxes in the uk, us, and germany over two generations kuznets looks at family units. Dec 09, 2014 income inequality hurts economic growth. So a decline in the middle income class may have serious economic and political consequences. Much depends on the extent to which a government has a welfare and tax system in place to provide an income safetynet and also a desire to redistribute rising incomes and wealth so that the benefits of growth can be more equitably shared out. The new oecd analysis found a negative and statistically significant correlation between income inequality and economic growth.
These analyses are meaningful in that it can help people better understand inequality. However, when income has kept rising and reached a high level, income inequality increases again. Reexamining the links klaus deininger and lyn squire many economists have long believed that income disparities increase in the early stages of development, making the poor relatively worse off. Ferreira june 1999 text for world banks web site on inequality, poverty, and socio economic performance. The analysis of income inequality and economic growth relationship. The central theme of this paper is the character and causes of longterm changes in the personal distribution of income. It would seem that he was reasonably correct as well. The empirical relationship reconsidered in the light of comparable data by stephen knowles abstract all of the recent empirical work on the relationship between income inequality and economic growth has used inequality data that are not consistently measured. Is there an environmental kuznets curve for biodiversity. Focus on inequality and growth december 2014 directorate for employment, labour and social affairs does income inequality hurt economic growth. Comparative evidence for subsaharan africa prepared by dalia hakura, mumtaz hussain, monique newiak, vimal thakoor, and fan yang1 authorized for distribution by celine allard june 2016 abstract a growing body of empirical evidence suggests that inequalityincome or gender relatedcan. I do so by using a dynamic panel estimator to estimate a growth equation and an income inequality equation that. They concluded that income inequality was the reason why economic growth was relatively inefficient at reducing poverty.
The relationship between inequality and economic growth is complex. Apr 06, 2018 why income inequality is holding back economic growth, in one chart published. Why income inequality is holding back economic growth, in one. Data for 35 countries over different periods in the last four decades were employed. The relationship between economic growth and income inequality 7 development of south korea and taiwan was not accompanied by an increase in income inequality. He became a student of wesley mitchell at columbia and subsequently a researcher at mitchells national bureau of economic research nber in 1926. Inequality and growth national bureau of economic research. Income inequality and economic growth sciencedirect. The relationship between income inequality and economic development has popularly been characterized by the kuznets invertedu curve kuznets, 1955, which argued that income inequality tends to increase at an initial stage of development and then decrease as the economy develops, implying that income inequality will fall as income continues to rise in developing countries. Income inequality has widened in most oecd member countries during the past two or three decades. We find a robust invertedu relationship between income inequality and political development, but not one between income inequality and economic development. Mar 29, 2017 many studies have estimated the effect of circumstances on income acquisition. Yet, an evergrowing income inequality risks harming future growth by creating support for bad policies.
If inequality turns out to be a negative factor in economic growth. New international panel data with the first internally consistent time series for a large number of countries shows no evidence of a kuznets curve. Pdf a long time ago, economic growth was the main indicator of countries economic health. In a neoclassical growth framework with a typical politicaleconomy mechanism, this paper reexamines the relationship between the income inequality and economic growth by introducing government spending into the production function and the utility function. Income inequality, foreign direct investment, mergers. Simon kuznets is best known for his studies of national income and its components. The great rise of inequality let us start by examining the ongoing trends in income and wealth. This paper estimates a panel model in which the relationship between inequality and gross domestic product per capita growth depends on countries initial incomes. The kuznets curve is the graph of income inequality ordinate variable against the movement of workers from rural subsistence agriculture into more modern sectors of the economy abscissa. Panizza 1999 joins the debate on income inequality by finding channels linking inequality to economic growth. Human capital accumulation is an important channel through which income inequality affects growth. We define economy i and economy ii as the economy with high progressive tax and low progressive tax. We also make a brief analysis of income inequality and poverty in romania.
1627 280 764 579 61 1068 535 476 515 662 1635 98 1283 1080 817 1147 21 1353 531 762 1233 861 123 606 1037 241 462 82 1364 1551 1582 218 1374 1538 864 1378 1606 684 331 859 110 987 106 1359 363 370 631 988 376